Skip to main content
Meraki Realty
Legal Compliance14 min read

Good Cause Eviction Law in NYC: A Landlord's Guide to Coverage, the Required Notice, and Non-Renewals (2026)

NYC's Good Cause Eviction law for owners: who's covered in 2026, the notice every lease needs (exempt units too), the 10 grounds, and the 8.38% standard.

By Meraki Realty|
A row of pre-war apartment buildings with brownstone stoops and fire escapes on a tree-lined New York street: under the Good Cause Eviction law, each apartment's coverage depends on its building, its owner and its rent

New York's Good Cause Eviction law, Real Property Law Article 6-A, has applied in New York City since April 20, 2024. If it covers an apartment, the owner can't evict the tenant or decline to renew the lease without one of ten reasons the law lists, proven in court. Covered or exempt, every lease needs the Good Cause notice.

Two and a half years in, the law's sharpest edge for owners has been paperwork. In the case summaries of Fordham Law School's Housing Court Decisions Project, we counted 95 Good Cause decisions from June 2024 through October 2026. Owners lost 65 of them, and 51 of those losses turned on documents rather than on whether the owner had a valid reason: 25 on defects in the notices served before the case, 18 on the small-landlord ownership disclosure, and 8 on other notice and petition defects. Owners won possession in two. The collection is a curated sample, not every case filed, and most of those losses were dismissals the owner could refile. A dismissal still means new notices and starting over.

The forms don't help. Both versions of the Good Cause notice posted on HPD's website print the same eviction ground twice and leave one out.

This guide covers Good Cause Eviction in NYC from the owner's side: how to tell whether an apartment is covered, with the 2026 numbers; how to fill in the notice so it holds up; the ten grounds and what each takes to prove; and the rent rule in brief. For the wider legal picture, start with our NYC landlord-tenant law guide.

What the Good Cause Eviction Law Does (and Doesn't)

The New York State Good Cause Eviction law applies in New York City automatically. Since April 20, 2024, a covered tenant can be removed only by a court order based on one of ten grounds, even after the lease ends. Increases above the local rent standard, 8.38% for 2026, are presumed unreasonable. The law expires June 15, 2034.

The law doesThe law doesn't
Require one of ten listed grounds, proven in court, to evict or not renew a covered tenant, with or without a written leaseLet you end a covered tenancy because the lease ran out, the building sold, or the apartment could rent for more
Presume an increase above the local rent standard unreasonableCap rent. A higher increase is legal; it may have to be defended with costs in court
Require every landlord to put the Good Cause notice on five kinds of documentsCover rent-stabilized apartments. They're exempt, but their leases still carry the notice
Void any lease clause that waives its protectionsCome with an agency that enforces it, or a registry you can check

There's no overcharge claim, and the law gives tenants only one lawsuit of their own: a tenant removed on an owner-use, demolition or withdrawal claim that turns out to be fraudulent can sue for actual damages and attorneys' fees. Everything else works as a defense in Housing Court. As HPD's own page puts it, Good Cause "is enforced through the courts."

Article 6-A itself hasn't been amended since it passed. The numbers change every year: the state housing agency, DHCR, must publish the inflation figure behind the rent standard and the luxury-rent lines by August 1.

Is Your Building Covered? The Exemption Test, in the Order to Run It

In New York City, every apartment is covered unless an exemption applies, and nobody can look it up for you. There's no registry, no agency determination, and we found no published count of how many apartments the final law covers. The owner runs the tests, apartment by apartment, and records the answer on the notice.

Run them in this order. The first four turn on documents: the rent registration, a regulatory agreement, the offering plan, the certificate of occupancy. The last three turn on who lives there, who owns it, and what it rents for.

StepThe testTurns onIf yes: exempt (notice box)
1Is the apartment rent-stabilized, rent-controlled or otherwise rent- or eviction-regulated?The apartmentBox D. The lease still carries the notice
2Is the rent restricted to an income level by a regulatory agreement or restrictive declaration?The apartmentBox E
3Is the building a condo or co-op, or under an offering plan filed with the Attorney General?The buildingBox F
4Was a temporary or permanent certificate of occupancy issued for the building on or after January 1, 2009?The buildingBox G, for 30 years from the certificate
5Does the owner live in the building, and does it have 10 or fewer units?The buildingBox C
6Does every person behind the ownership hold 10 or fewer units in New York State?The ownerBox B, plus a full ownership disclosure in any eviction case
7Is the rent above the 2026 luxury line for the apartment's size?The apartment's current rentBox N
—Rarer: seasonal units, hotel rooms, dormitories, religious facilities, hospitals and senior facilities, manufactured homesVariesBoxes H through M

Rent-stabilized apartments run on their own, stricter regime; our guide to rent-stabilized vs. rent-controlled apartments covers it. The point here is that "exempt" doesn't mean "no paperwork."

Step 4 covers few of the buildings this guide is written for. In our analysis of the city's PLUTO property database, about 3% of the homes in Manhattan buildings with 5 to 50 units are in buildings built in 2009 or later (9,343 of 320,127). Citywide, across all building sizes, the figure is about one home in ten, and a second city dataset that dates buildings by their certificate of occupancy agrees.

Step 5 looks only at the building. An owner who lives in a 6-unit building is exempt there even if they own 40 units elsewhere. Those other buildings are covered.

Does Good Cause apply to my building? In New York City, assume it does until one of the Good Cause Eviction exemptions applies. Check, in order: rent regulation, income restrictions, condo or co-op status, a certificate of occupancy issued in 2009 or later, an owner living in a building of 10 or fewer units, every owner holding 10 or fewer units statewide, and rent above the 2026 luxury line.

A pre-war building on the Upper West Side, the Upper East Side, the East Village or in Greenwich Village can hold all three kinds of apartment at once: stabilized, covered and exempt. When we take on a building or a listing, we work out each apartment's Good Cause status: covered or exempt, and under which exemption. That answer drives every lease and notice that follows.

How the 10-Unit Small-Landlord Count Works

The small-landlord exemption is where the court decisions cluster: 27 of the 95 catalogued decisions turned on the owner's ownership disclosure. The rules come from the statute's definition:

  • It's counted per person, statewide. Every natural person with an ownership interest, direct or indirect, whole or partial, through any LLC or affiliated entity, has to hold 10 or fewer units in New York State. If one of them holds 11, the landlord isn't a small landlord.
  • A partial stake counts in full. Read plainly, the statute counts a 1% interest in a 20-unit building as 20 units for that person.
  • Every owner has to be named. An entity that can't name every natural person behind it can't qualify.
  • Out-of-state units don't count. The test is units "in the state."

Here's how that plays out. Two partners each own half of an LLC that holds an 8-unit building. One of them also owns 30% of a 12-unit building with other investors. On the statute's plain reading, that partner's count is 20, so the 8-unit building doesn't qualify, even though the building itself has only eight units. If the 8-unit building is owner-occupied, step 5 can still exempt it.

Claiming the exemption starts with box B on the notice. If a case goes to court, the owner has to give the tenant the name of each natural-person owner, the number of units each holds, and their addresses, excluding each owner's principal residence. The petition has to include that disclosure. Judges have disagreed about whether it also belongs in the notice served before the case, so the safe practice is to put it in both. An owner who discloses only New York City holdings, or who can't account for every entity, invites dismissal.

We record each owner's total unit count, across every entity, to document the small-landlord exemption.

The 2026 Luxury Line

An apartment is exempt if its monthly rent is greater than 245% of HUD's Fair Market Rent for its size, as DHCR publishes it each year. The 2026 lines, posted July 16, 2026, are the same in all five boroughs:

Apartment size2026 line: exempt if the monthly rent is more than2025 line
Studio$6,196$5,471
One bedroom$6,505$5,709
Two bedrooms$7,130$6,321
Three bedrooms$8,928$7,877
Four bedrooms$9,700$8,499

Three details matter. "Rent" leaves out separately paid charges for parking, storage or a gym, unless they're set up to get around the law. The lines rose 13% to 14% for 2026, so an apartment that cleared last year's line can be covered this year; check it against the current line at every renewal. And the lines sit above typical Manhattan rents. In January 2026 the median new one-bedroom lease in Manhattan was $4,750, about $1,750 under the line, according to Miller Samuel and Douglas Elliman. The median three-bedroom lease, $8,080, cleared the 2025 line and falls short of the 2026 one.

The Good Cause Notice (RPL §231-c): A Checklist That Holds Up in Court

The Good Cause notice is a fill-in form set out word for word in Real Property Law §231-c. Since August 18, 2024, every landlord, covered or exempt, must attach it to every new lease, renewal lease, §226-c increase or non-renewal notice, 14-day rent demand and eviction petition. It states whether the apartment is covered and, if not, why.

DocumentWhenWhat the notice has to show
New leaseEvery oneCovered or exempt, and every exemption that applies
Renewal leaseEvery oneThe same
§226-c notice: a renewal increase of 5% or more, or a non-renewalAt least 30, 60 or 90 days before the lease ends, by tenureFor a covered apartment, the justification for an increase above 8.38%, or the ground for not renewing
14-day rent demandBefore any nonpayment caseCovered or exempt, and why
Eviction petitionEvery caseThe notice, plus why the apartment is exempt; the ownership disclosure if the owner claims the small-landlord exemption

The statute's list is closed. A 10-day notice to cure and a lease-based termination notice aren't on it, unless the termination is the §226-c non-renewal notice. Attaching the notice to those as well costs nothing and takes an argument off the table.

Which form? The text the law requires is printed in the statute itself, and no agency form is mandated. DHCR doesn't publish a tenant version: what it calls its "Good Cause Eviction Law Notice" is the annual publication of the inflation figure and the luxury lines. HPD's website posts fill-in templates, and those have a problem.

WarningHPD's template is missing a ground

Both versions of the notice on HPD's website, a fillable one and a plain one, both dated 2024, print item J of question 4 as a copy of item I: "illegal purpose." The ground the statute puts at J, a tenant's unreasonable refusal of access for legally required repairs or to show the apartment to a buyer or lender, isn't on either form. If that's your ground, use the statute's wording for item J.

The notice asks four questions, and mistakes on them have cost owners cases:

  1. Is the apartment subject to Good Cause? Answer yes or no every time. Never leave it blank.
  2. If it's exempt, why? Check every exemption that applies; a rent-stabilized apartment in a condo is D and F. Never check A in New York City. It's the box for municipalities outside the city that haven't adopted the law.
  3. Is the rent going up by more than the standard? For a covered apartment with an increase above 8.38%, check B and write the justification in the statute's terms: taxes, utilities, insurance, maintenance, significant repairs.
  4. Why isn't the lease being renewed? On an exempt apartment, check A and nothing else. On a new or renewal lease for a covered apartment, check B ("a first lease or a renewal lease") and nothing else. On a non-renewal of a covered apartment, check the specific ground.

Take a 20-unit pre-war rental building with 12 rent-stabilized apartments and 8 market-rate ones, owned by an LLC whose principal holds 40 units statewide, none of the market-rate rents above the luxury line. The stabilized renewals carry the notice answered "no," with box D checked. The market-rate leases carry it answered "yes," with box B checked in question 4. If one market-rate renewal goes up 9%, its §226-c notice also needs question 3 answered with the justification. One building, three versions of the same form.

The decisions in Fordham's catalogue show where owners fall down. Owners lost when the Good Cause form was missing from the termination notice or rent demand served before the case, when it was cut short, and when it contradicted itself, as when one form said the apartment both was and wasn't covered. They lost when the form used the outside-the-city box, and when it was dated months after the notice it was supposed to travel with. Several judges have held that a defective notice served before the case can't be fixed by amending later: the case is dismissed and the owner starts over. Judges have split on defects in the petition itself.

The checklist that follows from those cases:

  1. Use the statute's full text, with item J corrected.
  2. Fill in the complete apartment address.
  3. Answer question 1 every time.
  4. Make the boxes agree: an apartment can't be both covered and exempt.
  5. Write the justification or the ground wherever the form asks for one.
  6. Serve the notice with the document it rides on, dated the same day.
  7. Keep a copy and proof of delivery in the apartment's file.

Every lease we draft, for leasing and management clients alike, carries the Good Cause notice, whether the apartment is covered or exempt. For the buildings we manage, the notice goes on every renewal lease and every §226-c increase or non-renewal notice.

Notices, renewals and the apartment file, handled

For the buildings we manage, we set each apartment's Good Cause status, put the notice on every lease, renewal and §226-c notice, and keep each owner's unit count on file.

See Our Property Management

Good Cause Eviction Rent Increase Rules: 8.38% Is a Presumption, Not a Cap

For 2026, the local rent standard in New York City is 8.38%: 5% plus the 3.38% rise in the New York-area consumer price index, never more than 10%. An increase at or below it can't be found unreasonable. An increase above it is presumed unreasonable, and the owner can rebut that with cost evidence.

The standard was 8.82% in 2024 and 8.79% in 2025. On a $2,000 apartment, 8.38% is $167.60, for a new rent of $2,167.60.

The presumption matters in court, in two situations: a nonpayment case where the arrears come from an above-standard increase, and a non-renewal based on a tenant refusing an increase. A tenant who pays a higher increase has no lawsuit under Good Cause to get it back.

The statute tells the court what to weigh. It shall consider property taxes and recent increases in them. It may consider fuel and other utilities, insurance, maintenance, and significant repairs: the replacement or substantial modification of a structural, electrical, plumbing or mechanical system, not cosmetic work, and not work made necessary by the owner's failure to maintain. As of November 2026, we found no reported decision ruling on whether an owner's evidence rebutted the presumption. Our guide to how much a landlord can raise rent in NYC covers that evidence in detail.

TipBuild the file before the renewal goes out

An above-standard increase is defended with tax bills, insurance invoices, utility bills and repair records. Gather them before the renewal goes out, not after a tenant contests it. Our rent increase guide lists what belongs in the file.

Three Clocks in One Building

A building with stabilized and market-rate apartments runs on three renewal calendars at once:

ClockApplies toTiming
Stabilized renewal offerRent-stabilized apartments150 to 90 days before the lease ends (Rent Stabilization Code §2523.5)
§226-c noticeAny renewal with an increase of 5% or more, or any non-renewalAt least 30, 60 or 90 days before the lease ends: under one year, one to two years, or two years or more of occupancy or lease length, whichever is longer
Ground (j) notice of changesCovered apartments, to keep the right not to renew if the tenant refuses30 to 90 days before the lease ends

For a tenant of two years or more, the §226-c minimum and the ground (j) maximum meet at 90 days. We walk through that squeeze in our rent increase guide. Keeping three calendars straight across one building is the kind of work our property management team does.

Non-Renewal and Eviction: The Ten Grounds and What Each Takes to Prove

Can a landlord refuse to renew a lease in NYC? For a market-rate apartment exempt from Good Cause, yes, with the §226-c notice. For a covered apartment, only on one of ten grounds, proven in court; a lease ending, a sale, or a chance to rent for more isn't one of them. Rent-stabilized tenants have their own right to a renewal.

GroundWhat the owner has to show
(a) NonpaymentRent due and unpaid, not the result of an unreasonable increase
(b) Lease violationA substantial obligation broken, a written notice to cure within 10 days, and no cure. Building rules count only if reasonable and accepted in writing
(c) Nuisance or damageA nuisance, substantial damage done maliciously or through gross negligence, or conduct that interferes with others' comfort and safety
(d) Illegal occupancyAn agency order to vacate, for a condition the owner didn't create
(e) Illegal useThe tenant used, or let others use, the apartment or building for an illegal purpose
(f) Refused accessAn unreasonable refusal of access for legally required repairs or improvements, or to show the apartment to a buyer, lender or other party with a legitimate interest
(g) Owner or family useGood faith, by clear and convincing evidence, for the owner's or a listed relative's principal residence, with no other suitable apartment in the building. Not available against a tenant who is 65 or older or disabled
(h) DemolitionGood faith, by clear and convincing evidence
(i) Withdrawal from the marketGood faith, by clear and convincing evidence
(j) Refused renewal termsReasonable changes, with any increase not unreasonable, and written notice 30 to 90 days before the lease ends

The heaviest proof sits on (g), (h) and (i), and those three carry the law's one tenant lawsuit: a tenant removed on a fraudulent owner-use, demolition or withdrawal claim can recover actual damages and attorneys' fees. In a nonpayment case, the tenant also keeps the right to pay what's owed and stay.

Grounds (b), (f) and (j) are won or lost on the file: the cure notice and proof it was served, the written access requests, the renewal terms and the date they went out. Our guide to the NYC eviction process covers how a holdover case moves once it's filed.

What Has Changed Since 2024, and What Hasn't

Article 6-A hasn't been amended. The numbers have: the rent standard went from 8.82% to 8.79% to 8.38%, and the luxury lines rose 13% to 14% for 2026. DHCR posted the 2026 figures on July 16, 2026 and reposted them on August 17.

The courts are still working the law out, almost entirely at the trial level. Of the 95 catalogued decisions, two came from the Appellate Term and none from a higher court. Judges have split on whether a defective notice can be fixed and on where the ownership disclosure belongs. We found no reported decision yet on an owner's evidence to rebut the rent presumption, and no constitutional challenge to the statewide law.

Several amendment bills moved in Albany in 2026, and one passed the State Senate. None became law, and the legislative session has ended.

LegalQuestions the law doesn't answer yet

Whether a spouse's units count toward the 10, whether exempt units count, and what counts as a "unit." What "owner-occupied" means. Whether a new certificate of occupancy for an old building, after a conversion or gut renovation, triggers the 2009 exemption. When the luxury line is measured. How an LLC landlord uses the owner-use ground. If your plan depends on one of these, get a lawyer's opinion first. This guide is general information, not legal advice.

Frequently Asked Questions

The Bottom Line

Good Cause comes down to three jobs: know each apartment's status, put a correct notice on every lease and notice, and keep the file that proves a ground or an increase. The law runs until June 15, 2034, and its numbers change every summer. A pre-war building can hold stabilized, covered and exempt apartments under one roof, each with its own paperwork and its own clock. That's the work our property management team does for the buildings we manage.

If a building hasn't been checked since 2025, start with the luxury lines. They rose 13% to 14% for 2026, and an apartment that cleared last year's line may be covered this year.

Get each apartment's status on paper

Tell us about your building. We'll show you how we set each apartment's Good Cause status, paper every lease and renewal, and keep the records behind an above-standard increase.

Contact Meraki Realty